Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls | Prediction & 62% Away

Match Preview

Columbus Crew hosts New York Red Bulls on 12 September 2026 at Lower.com Field, both teams struggling to regain form. Columbus have lost five consecutive matches, conceding 12 goals in that span, highlighting defensive vulnerabilities. Artur’s absence due to a right hip injury weakens their creative options upfront. At home, Crew have failed to capitalize recently, scoring just 4 goals in their last 5 home games.

New York Red Bulls arrive winless in five MLS matches, with two draws and three losses, conceding 9 goals across those games. Key defensive players Ryan Meara (groin) and Aaron Long (achilles) are sidelined, raising questions about their backline stability. Despite this, New York’s recent away form shows resilience, with 3 points from their last 5 away fixtures and a slightly better goal return of 6 goals scored.

Historically, Columbus holds a narrow edge with 12 wins in the last 24 meetings, but New York eked out a 3–2 victory in their previous encounter in May. Given both sides’ poor recent form and multiple injuries, this game leans toward a low-scoring, tight contest. Columbus’ defensive issues and New York’s missing defensive leaders give the visitors a slight tactical edge, though a draw or narrow away win is plausible. Columbus Crew hold about a 40% win probability, with New York close behind at 35%.

Team Form

Columbus’ recent form is misleading when extended to the last 5 matches overall, including a single win and four losses, but the injury list is heavy and their defense is leaking badly. New York’s form is better overall, but recent results have dipped, with injuries to key defenders likely impacting their solidity.

Columbus’ home goal output is low, while New York’s attack is more productive on the road, which could be decisive in this matchup.